Oct 30, 2024; New York, New York, USA; New York Yankees pitcher Clay Holmes (35) throws during the seventh inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers in game five of the 2024 MLB World Series at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

mlb

Mets sign ex-Yankees closer Clay Holmes to 3-year, $38M deal

Clay Holmes joins Mets as starter in bold $38M move.

The Mets are making headlines again, this time by signing Clay Holmes—the Yankees’ closer—to a three-year, $38 million deal. But here’s the twist: they’re not keeping him in the bullpen. Holmes is going to be a starter. That’s the plan, and it’s very… Mets.

Clay Holmes signs with the Mets pic.twitter.com/1S8mGTcmhA
— Talkin’ Baseball (@TalkinBaseball_) December 7, 2024

Holmes, known for his filthy sinker that kept hitters pounding the ball into the ground (a league-leading 64.6% ground-ball rate last year), hasn’t started a game since 2018. Back then, he was with the Pirates, just trying to figure things out.

But the Mets seem to think he’s got what it takes to go multiple innings. He’s got three pitches: that sinker, plus a slider and a sweeper. Enough for a starter? Maybe. Enough to make this move interesting? Definitely.

Why this move might work

This isn’t the first time a reliever has been turned into a starter. Look at Seth Lugo. He left the Mets, joined the Padres, and suddenly became a Cy Young-caliber starter in Kansas City. Then there’s Michael King, who went from bullpen weapon for the Yankees to standout starter for the Padres. It’s a trend, and the Mets want in.

The Mets plan to turn Clay Holmes into a starter, per @JeffPassan.

Holmes last started a game in 2018.
— Underdog MLB (@Underdog__MLB) December 7, 2024

Holmes has had his ups and downs. Last year, he blew 13 saves and lost the Yankees’ closer role by September. But he also made the All-Star team, saved 30 games, and posted a solid 3.14 ERA. Over the past four seasons, he’s been reliable—3.05 ERA across nearly 260 innings. The stuff is there. The consistency is the question.

The Mets’ rotation is a patchwork in progress

The Mets’ rotation is kind of a mess right now. Kodai Senga and David Peterson are still there, but beyond that? Frankie Montas came in on a $34 million deal, but he’s more of a wild card than a sure thing. Losing Luis Severino, Sean Manaea, and José Quintana left holes that aren’t exactly filled yet.

Clay Holmes gave the Yankees 3+ years of incredible relief/closer work, and has easily been a top 5-7 reliever in baseball over that stretch.

The non ball knowers are celebrating his departure today. However, Ball Knowers Anonymous is sad to see him go.

The Mets got a good one pic.twitter.com/eeu3iu9q4N
— Kin Knows Ball (@_24kin) December 7, 2024

Holmes isn’t the typical starter they’d go for, but he might be what they need. They’ve done this before—taking pitchers who aren’t perfect fits and making them work. Sean Manaea and Severino were signed to short-term deals last year and outperformed expectations. Maybe Holmes can do the same. Maybe not. That’s the risk.

Is this about Holmes, or is it all about Soto?

This move seems very budget-conscious. Holmes’ deal is affordable, especially compared to what top relievers or starters are getting this offseason. Severino’s getting $22.3 million per year from the A’s. Holmes? Just over $12 million annually. The Mets aren’t splurging right now, and that’s probably because they’re saving every last dollar for Juan Soto.

Frankie Montas thoughts on the potential of Juan Soto to the #Mets (translation) :

“ man who wouldn’t want a baseball player of that caliber here; the whole world will want that type of player on their team. Now this is up to him this is his path on where he wants to go. If I… pic.twitter.com/IOVkpfEFxX
— 𝐊𝐄𝐄𝐅🇵🇷 (@KickinitwitKeef) December 6, 2024

The Mets want Soto. Badly. They’re making smaller moves, avoiding anything too flashy or expensive, and leaving room for what could be a franchise-changing signing. If they land Soto, this offseason suddenly looks brilliant. If not? Well, then every move gets overanalyzed. Including this one.

The verdict on Holmes

So, is Holmes a smart pickup? Hard to say yet. The upside is there. If he can handle a starter’s workload, the Mets might have found a steal. If not, he’s still a solid bullpen option. Either way, it’s not a disaster.

Clay Holmes

Clay Holmes 3-year deal

Clay Holmes Mets

Clay Homes $38M deal

Mets sign Clay Holmes

Natasha Bose

I write about sports because, well, it brings in the big bucks! I’m not some lifelong analyst or stats guru, truth being told, you’ve probably never heard of me!—I just know how to research, write, and make things sound good. That’s the job!
Got into sports media the same way most people do: by (fortunate) accident. Started with SEO writing, took on a few sports gigs, and now here we are! I cover games, trades, player drama—whatever needs words.
Favorite part? The chaos. One day it’s a blockbuster trade, the next it’s a goat running onto the field. Never boring.
Message to readers: If you want deep analysis, there are people for that. If you want sharp, no-BS writing that actually makes sense, stick around.