Juan Soto’s still finding his footing.
Juan Soto didn’t jog out a couple of grounders. In most cases, it’s the kind of thing that earns a passing mention, if that. But when you’re carrying a $765 million contract in New York, every slow step becomes an invitation for a firestorm.
After back-to-back games where Soto visibly didn’t run out balls, once in the Bronx, then again in Boston, the criticism came fast. The optics didn’t help: the Mets lost both games, the offense sputtered, and Soto didn’t exactly rush to smooth things over. He skipped postgame media Sunday and, after Monday’s loss, offered a shrug: “I think I’ve been hustling pretty hard. If you saw it today, you could tell.”
In an attempt to cut down the go-ahead run in the eighth inning, Pete Alonso threw well wide of home plate. The Mets are down to their final three outs. pic.twitter.com/F5UGfiJLcj
— Anthony DiComo (@AnthonyDiComo) May 19, 2025
That kind of response, indifferent at best, only added fuel to a conversation that’s quickly expanded beyond effort. This isn’t just about not running to first. It’s about expectations, about adaptation, and about what it means when a player chooses the Mets over the Yankees, especially this player.
Soto picked the Mets after a strong season in the Bronx, spurning a reported $760 million offer from the Yankees to ink a record-setting 15-year deal, $765 million deal with their crosstown rivals. His decision drew headlines, admiration, and yes, scrutiny. And now, just two months into his new chapter, every misstep is magnified.
Carlos Mendoza isn’t jumping on that pile. The Mets manager addressed Soto’s effort with him, or at least said he planned to, but declined to share any details or even confirm if the meeting happened. What he did do was offer some necessary perspective.
ALSO READ: Giancarlo Stanton Injury Update: No Timeline Yet, but Recovery Nearing Finish Line?
“He’s human. He’s 26, man,” Mendoza said. “He’s going to be fine. He’s Juan Soto.” Mendoza acknowledged the adjustment period, and didn’t shy away from the reality that even a World Series winner like Soto is navigating unfamiliar terrain.
"It starts with me, as the manager. My job is to block that noise."
— SNY (@SNYtv) May 20, 2025
Carlos Mendoza was asked how difficult it can be for Juan Soto and other Mets players to block out the outside noise: pic.twitter.com/VgP6bfECeb
“I think he’s comfortable, but everything is new, not only a new team, but just the new contract, the expectations. He’s always been on winning teams and won a World Series. But this is new territory for him. That’s our job as an organization to continue to help him.”
Soto’s numbers aren’t disastrous, he’s slashing .247/.379/.437, but they’re noticeably down from his career line of .285/.421/.532. And the Mets have lost more than just a step lately. After leading the NL East for weeks, they’ve dropped three straight, gone 4-6 in their last 10, and fallen behind the surging Phillies. The offense, once electric, is now ice cold: just 5-for-44 with runners in scoring position over the past week.
“Even though it’s still New York, it’s a new team, it’s a new franchise, new fan base, everything,” said Mets veteran Brandon Nimmo. “He has to do everything a little bit differently. It’s not exactly the same as it was there. He’s settling into it, and honestly, he’s human. For where we’re at, he’s still doing great.”
Juan Soto keeps the home run party going at Citi Field! 🍎 pic.twitter.com/SH0bstikWp
— MLB (@MLB) May 10, 2025
The Mets were shut out Tuesday in Boston, managing just four hits in a 2-0 loss. Soto went 1-for-3 with a walk and a strikeout. It was quiet, but not terrible, much like his season so far. But the contract size, the pinstripes in the rearview, and the stakes of New York baseball mean quiet doesn’t go unnoticed.
Juan Soto is still finding his rhythm. And for now, at least, Carlos Mendoza is giving him the space to do it.
ALSO READ: Mets, Juan Soto Might Not See Eye to Eye on What Hustling Means
It’s easy to forget, given everything he’s already accomplished, a World Series ring, five Silver Sluggers, multiple All-Star nods, and now the richest contract in MLB history, that Juan Soto is only 26. The resume almost says seasoned veteran, but he’s still just a few years removed from being a prodigy.
Mohsin Baldiwala is a Master's student in Journalism and freelance content producer who got hooked on baseball through Seinfeld's hapless George Costanza. The same reason why he's a Yankees fan. He writes about sports because he believes it can offer a brief escape from the world's chaos. Even if that means enduring the heartbreak of the 2024 World Series.
Read moreGet the biggest stories delivered straight to you - for free!
By signing up, you consent to our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy, nad to receive marketing and account-related emails from The Playoffs. You can subscribe at any time.
For over 10 years, The Playoffs has been a go-to source for sports and sports betting enthusiasts.
Our mission: To help bettors make the best choices with in-depth analysis, reliable data, and passionate expertise.
Our motto: Share our passion for sports and betting. At The Playoffs, we live and breathe sports. Every day, our editorial teams work to deliver the most accurate and relevant information so you can place bets with confidence—and most importantly, enjoy the experience.
Gambling can be fun and exciting, but it’s essential to keep it responsible. Set limits on your time and spending, never chase your losses, and understand that betting is a form of entertainment—not a way to earn money. If gambling stops being enjoyable or starts affecting your life negatively, don’t hesitate to seek support or take advantage of self-exclusion tools provided by betting platforms. Remember, responsible betting is the key to a safe and enjoyable gaming experience.
DISCLAIMER: This site is 100% for entertainment purposes only and does not involve real money betting. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler.
COPYRIGHT © 2025 - THE PLAYOFFS - SHARE THE PASSION FOR SPORTS AND BETTING