Sports
Picks & Odds
Betting Guide
Casinos
Missouri
NFL NFL
Sports Picks & Odds Betting Guide Casinos Missouri
Gambling is prohibited for underage individuals | Commercial content | Regional restrictions may apply | T&Cs apply | Play responsibly

Pittsburgh Steelers vs Indianapolis Colts Predictions, Odds, and Best Bets for Week 9 NFL 2025-26 Season

Eric Divakaran
American Football / NFL
02/11/2025 – 19:00
Pittsburgh Steelers
VS
19:00
02/11/2025
Indianapolis Colts
Odds updated on November 1, 2025 at 1:52 pm

The Pittsburgh Steelers will take on the Indianapolis Colts for Week 9 matchup. The Steelers are coming into this matchup with a with a 4-3 record, after initially starting their season 4-1. They’ve dropped the last two games against the Bengals, and the Packers, and their offensive and defensive holes were clear to see, going up against better competition. While they are still above .500 relying on Aaron Rodgers, they are still missing some pieces on offensive and defensive side of the field, before they become true contenders.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Steelers History (@steelershistory)

Meanwhile, the Indianapolis Colts, with a 7-1 record this season, are on a four-game winning streak, with their only loss coming against the Los Angeles Rams. Whether it’s the micro-managing by the team’s owner, or their QB and RB having an amazing season, everything is working for the Colts so far. They are also the only team in the NFL win a single loss this season, and with Daniel Jones and their star RB Jonathan Taylor having an astounding season, we do not see this team slowing down anytime soon.

Recommended Bets and Updated Odds

Recommended Bets FanduelBetMGM
Aaron Rodgers over 0.5 interceptions -130-105
Daniel Jones under 34.5 passing attempts-128-120
Jonathan Taylor anytime TD scorer-280-250
Bet $5 Win $250 in Bonus Bets
Click to reveal code
COPIED
F A N D U V I P
Claim $250
21+ and present in AZ/CO/CT/IA/IL/IN/KS/LA (permitted parishes only) /MA/MD/MI/NJ/NY/OH/PA/TN/VA/WV/WY. Minimum $10 first deposit required. Promotion Bonus will be credited to your account within 72 hours settlement of Qualifying Wager. First online real money wager only (minimum $5). Bonus issued as non-withdrawable bonus bets that expires in 14 days. Bonus bets and NFL Sunday Ticket code will be issued within 72 hours of bet placement. See full terms at sportsbook.fanduel.com.

Rationale and Analysis

Despite the Colts’ lapses in passing defense, they rank 11th in interceptions this season and Rodgers has thrown 5 interceptions this season, in 7 games. Defensive pressure, and Rodgers’ decision making to make big plays, especially if they’re down, could lead to Rodgers going over 0.5 INTs in this game.

We expect Daniel Jones to attempt less than 34.5 passes, as he’s not had a single game so far where he’s attempted over 34 passes this season. The Colts have a balanced attack of passing and running through Jonathan Taylor, which relieves pressure off of Jones to make plays. The Steelers struggle against the pass and the rush, which gives the Colts the versatility to use either of the weapons, making this a safe bet.

Jonathan Taylor has been on a tear lately, scoring 9 TDs in four games. He’s having an amazing season and looking at the Steelers’ weak run and scoring defense, 18th and 19th respectively, Taylor should be able to get a TD.

Steelers vs Colts Prediction

We expect the Colts to beat the Steelers because of the consistency and the rhythm that the Colts are currently on, beating most teams with ease. While the Steelers can make explosive plays at times, ultimately their defense, especially against the pass, if what may keep them from winning the game. Expect a high scoring battle between the two teams.

Prediction: Colts win the game 28-24

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Indianapolis Colts (@colts)

Week 9 Steelers vs Colts Spread and Betting Odds

Looking at the spread and the moneyline, the Colts are the favorites to beat the Steelers, as per BetMGM

TeamsSpreadTotal PointsMoneyline
Colts-3 (-115)50.5 (-110)-165
Steelers+3 (-105)50.5 (-110)+140
Get up to $1,500 Back in Bonus Bets
Click to copy code
COPIED
TPOPICKS
CLAIM $1500
21+. AZ/CO/IL/IN/IA/KS/LA/MD/MA/MI/NJ/OH/PA/TN/ VA/WV/WY only. Offer not available in DC/MS/NV/NY/PR. New customers only. Qualifying deposit (min $10) and first real money wager required. If qualifying bet settles as a loss, user is refunded 100% in non-withdrawable bonus bets up to $1,500. Full T&Cs can be found on betmgm.com.

If you’re looking for a complete guide to the best NFL betting sites, we’ve got you covered.

Steelers vs Colts Best Bets

Here is a look at over/under and best player bets for the Pittsburgh Steelers and the Indianapolis Colts, as per BetMGM

Pittsburgh Steelers Over/Under Odds

Listed below are over/under odds for the Pittsburgh Steelers, as per BetMGM

Over/Under BetsOverUnder
DK Metcalf receiving yards63.5 (-115)63.5 (-115)
Aaron Rodgers passing yards 239.5 (-115)239.5 (-118)
Jaylen Warren rushing yards60.5 (-110)60.5 (-118)

Pittsburgh Steelers Best Player Bets

Here are some of the best player bets for the Pittsburgh Steelers as per BetMGM

  • Jaylen Warren anytime TD scorer: +100
  • Kenneth Gainwell over 5.5 rushing attempts: -130
  • Aaron Rodgers over 1.5 passing TDs: -130

Indianapolis Colts Over/Under Odds

Listed below is over/under for the Indianapolis Colts, as per BetMGM.

Over/Under BetsOverUnder
Tyler Warren receiving yards54.5 (-115)54.5 (-115)
Daniel Jones passing yards255.5 (-115)255.5 (-115)
Jonathan Taylor rushing yards 95.5 (-115)95.5 (-115)

Indianapolis Colts Best Player Bets

Here are some of the best player bets for the Indianapolis Colts, as per BetMGM

  • Tyler Warren under 5.5 receptions made: -150
  • Michael Pittman over 4.5 receptions made: -160
  • Jonathan Taylor anytime TD scorer: -250
Get up to $1,500 Back in Bonus Bets
Click to copy code
COPIED
TPOPICKS
CLAIM $1500
21+. AZ/CO/IL/IN/IA/KS/LA/MD/MA/MI/NJ/OH/PA/TN/ VA/WV/WY only. Offer not available in DC/MS/NV/NY/PR. New customers only. Qualifying deposit (min $10) and first real money wager required. If qualifying bet settles as a loss, user is refunded 100% in non-withdrawable bonus bets up to $1,500. Full T&Cs can be found on betmgm.com.

(According to BetMGM: BetMGM offers exclusive promo codes, bonus deals and accurate odds for users upon signing up. Use BetMGM to ace your betting game in all sports!)

FAQs

Who is favored to win between the Steelers vs Colts?
The Colts are 3-point favorites to win the matchup against Steelers.

What is the over/under total for the game?
The over/under for total points is set at 50.

What is the predicted score for the Steelers vs Colts game?
We expect the Colts to take down the Steelers in a close battle, and the Final score to be 28-24.

nba nba
nfl nfl
mma mma

I cover the National Football League and things cannot get better than that. I always dreamed to play football or basketball professionally since I’m built like a Running Back. But now that I can’t, since I’m technically in the “Unc” age, I thought why not pick a career in sports industry? So here I am, doing what I love, and hoping that the Commanders win the Super Bowl. I give love to players when it’s due, but can be critical about their performances at the same time. Enough about me, now let my articles do all the talking. 

Read more