Sports
Picks & Odds
Betting Guide
Casinos
Missouri
Gambling is prohibited for underage individuals | Commercial content | Regional restrictions may apply | T&Cs apply | Play responsibly

Newcastle United vs Benfica Preview, Betting Odds and Predictions – 21/10/2025

Abhinav Goel
Soccer / UEFA Champions League
21/10/2025 – 20:00
Newcastle
VS
20:00
21/10/2025
Benfica
Odds updated on October 19, 2025 at 7:27 pm

Newcastle United return to European action on Tuesday night as they host a struggling Benfica side at St. James’ Park in their third Champions League group fixture. The Magpies are fresh from an impressive 4-0 victory over Union Saint-Gilloise in their last clash. They will look to continue their momentum, while the visitors are still searching for their first point of the campaign.

Eddie Howe’s side have had a mixed start to the season but showed their best version in Europe last time out. After falling 2-1 to Barcelona in their opener, Newcastle bounced back emphatically in Brussels. They produced a dominant performance that reignited their hopes of reaching the knockout rounds for the first time in their history. With confidence high and a passionate home crowd behind them, the Magpies will be eager to build on that success and make St. James’ Park a fortress.

Newcastle United vs Benfica Best Bets

BetsMoneylineMoneyline
Full Time ResultNewcastle United: -165, Benfica: +425Draw: +320
Draw No BetNewcastle United: -450Benfica: +275
Total GoalsOver 2.5: -145Under 2.5: +105
Newcastle United to Win and Both Teams to ScoreYes: +220No: +170
Benfica to Win and Both Teams to ScoreYes: +750No: +750

(Odds via BetMGM)

Newcastle United vs Benfica Preview

Consistency remains an issue for Newcastle. Their recent 2-1 Premier League defeat to Brighton ended a short winning streak and highlighted defensive vulnerabilities that Benfica could look to exploit. Howe’s men currently sit mid-table in Premier League but know that a win here would place them firmly in contention for qualification.

On the other hand, Benfica enter the contest under pressure after back-to-back defeats in the Champions League, including a narrow 1-0 loss to Chelsea and a shock 3-2 home defeat to Qarabag. Under new manager Jose Mourinho, the Portuguese giants are still finding their rhythm, though a recent 2-0 cup win over Chaves and a hard-fought draw against Porto in the league have steadied the ship somewhat.

Also Read: Marc Guehi Set To Leave Crystal Palace Next Year After Rejecting New Contract

Newcastle United vs Benfica Over/Under Predictions

Over 2.5 Goals @ -145 as per BetMGM

Over 2.5 Goals looks like a strong pick for Newcastle United vs Benfica, given both teams’ recent form and attacking tendencies. Newcastle’s last three wins have all come with clean attacking performances, including a 4-0 thrashing of Union Saint-Gilloise. With Newcastle eager to dominate at home and Benfica desperate to get their first Champions League points, this clash is likely to open up quickly, making three or more goals a strong possibility.

Get up to $1,500 Back in Bonus Bets
Click to copy code
COPIED
TPOPICKS
CLAIM $1500
21+. AZ/CO/IL/IN/IA/KS/LA/MD/MA/MI/NJ/OH/PA/TN/ VA/WV/WY only. Offer not available in DC/MS/NV/NY/PR. New customers only. Qualifying deposit (min $10) and first real money wager required. If qualifying bet settles as a loss, user is refunded 100% in non-withdrawable bonus bets up to $1,500. Full T&Cs can be found on betmgm.com.

Newcastle United vs Benfica Player Picks

Nick Woltemade to score anytime @ +115 as per BetMGM:

Nick Woltemade to score anytime at looks a good pick for this fixture. The German forward has been in excellent form since joining Newcastle, netting four goals in five Premier League matches and adding another in the Champions League. His sharp positioning and aerial presence make him a consistent threat inside the box, especially against a Benfica defense that has kept just one clean sheet in their last five games across all competitions. With Newcastle creating plenty of chances at home and Woltemade emerging as their focal point in attack, I am backing him to find the net again here.

Also Read: Ange Postecoglou Sacked After Record 39-Day Nottingham Forest Spell

Newcastle United vs Benfica Final Scoreline Prediction

With Newcastle’s attacking firepower and Benfica’s renewed determination under Mourinho, this clash promises to be an intriguing tactical battle. The Magpies’ energy and home advantage make them favorites, but the visitors’ experience in Europe means this could be closer than expected. This contest could have major implications for both sides’ hopes of progressing .

Final Prediction: Newcastle United 2-1 Benfica

Bettors can explore a variety of betting options on BetMGM, including full-time results, over/under goals, and player props for this clash.

soccer soccer

I am a soccer writer at The PlayOffs, covering everything from match analysis to transfer buzz and tactical deep dives. Ever since I was a kid, soccer has been more than just a sport to me—it’s been an obsession. Playing and watching the game from a young age fueled my passion, eventually leading me into the world of sports media and betting. Now, I get to analyze the sport I love and bring the latest updates to fans worldwide.

Read more