Christian McCaffrey and the Return of the Madden Curse

Christian McCaffrey and the Madden Curse: Bad luck strikes again.

The “Madden Curse” has long been a topic of debate among NFL fans, and 2024 seems to have added another chapter to its lore. Christian McCaffrey, the San Francisco 49ers’ star running back and cover athlete for Madden NFL 25, has endured a season marred by injuries that mirror the curse’s infamous reputation.

McCaffrey’s injury-plagued season

McCaffrey’s 2024 campaign has been anything but smooth. After missing most of training camp and the preseason due to calf and Achilles issues, his regular season started with another setback—he was ruled out of Week 1 at the last minute.

Christian McCaffrey has been ruled OUT for the reason of the season.

Let’s take a look at some of the WORST cases of MADDEN COVER CURSE

A thread 🧵 pic.twitter.com/cCBCo5qfKb
— Grammy! (@grandmaofthenfl) December 3, 2024

His return in Week 9 offered little reprieve as he struggled to regain his 2023 form, when he had won Offensive Player of the Year. Across four games, Christian McCaffrey managed just 348 scrimmage yards and failed to score a single touchdown before suffering a PCL injury in Week 13 against the Buffalo Bills.

The PCL injury, expected to sideline him for at least six weeks, has effectively ended McCaffrey’s season. “It’s a tough loss for us, but we have to adapt and move forward,” 49ers coach Kyle Shanahan told reporters.

The team, already reeling from injuries to key players like Brandon Aiyuk, Nick Bosa, and Talanoa Hufanga, has seen its playoff hopes dim. Sitting at 5-7, the 49ers look far removed from their Super Bowl-caliber squad of 2023.

What exactly is the ‘Madden Curse?’

The Madden Curse, which gained notoriety after Garrison Hearst’s 1998 cover appearance ended with a broken ankle, has continued to haunt players, particularly running backs. Of the 22 cover athletes since the curse’s inception, 16 have faced either injuries or significant dips in performance during the season following their cover debut.

Christian McCaffrey and his story is eerily reminiscent of past Madden cover stars like Shaun Alexander (Madden NFL 2007), whose MVP-level production plummeted after appearing on the cover.

Madden curse going ultra instinct on the 49ers.

– Ricky Shot
– Deebo Pneumonia
– Aiyuk ACL & MCL gone
– Hargrave Torn Peck
– Moody Kicking Ankle
– CMC no legs #FTTB pic.twitter.com/vwO110zC28
— Santa Trey 🎅🎄 (@Str8cash510) October 22, 2024

Similarly, Marshall Faulk (Madden NFL 2003) and Peyton Hillis (Madden NFL 2012) saw their careers derailed following their cover seasons. Hillis, in particular, went from a breakout 1,177-yard season to a meager 587 rushing yards the very next year—a case many fans consider the epitome of the curse.

Breaking the pattern—or not?

While some players like Tom Brady (Madden NFL 18) and Patrick Mahomes (Madden NFL 20 and 22) have seemingly avoided the curse, even they experienced minor setbacks. Brady’s first post-cover season was stellar, but his Patriots fell short in the Super Bowl.

Mahomes overcame his initial Madden Curse whispers only to face nagging injuries and team struggles in subsequent years.

THE MADDEN CURSE IS REAL. pic.twitter.com/SKl6CtxtH0
— MLFootball (@_MLFootball) December 2, 2024

EA Sports continues to dismiss the idea of a curse, chalking it up to coincidence or natural regression after exceptional seasons. However, the pattern is hard to ignore.

As one fan sarcastically put it, “Can teams ban their players from the cover? They should for the sake of their season.” Another joked, “The Madden Curse is as consistent as the sun rising—it just finds new ways to strike.”

Every member of the Madden Curse club

Here’s a rundown of some of the Madden Curse’s most memorable victims. You tell me if it’s just bad luck:

Garrison Hearst (Madden NFL 99): Broke his ankle and missed two entire seasons. First official curse victim.
Daunte Culpepper (Madden NFL 2002): Went from a 33-touchdown season to a disastrous 14-13 TD-INT ratio. Won just four games.
Marshall Faulk (Madden NFL 2003): One of the NFL’s best. Then his rushing yards per game fell off a cliff. Never hit 1,000 yards again.
Michael Vick (Madden NFL 2004): Broke his leg in the preseason. Missed most of the year. The Falcons were toast.
Ray Lewis (Madden NFL 2005): Five-time All-Pro before the cover. Missed 11 games after it.
Donovan McNabb (Madden NFL 2006): Super Bowl QB turned injury-prone disaster. Played just nine games and watched his numbers plummet.
Shaun Alexander (Madden NFL 2007): NFL MVP in 2005. The year after his cover? Couldn’t even hit 1,000 yards.
Peyton Hillis (Madden NFL 2012): The ultimate one-hit wonder. A Cinderella story in 2010. A ghost in 2011.

Even in recent years, players like Patrick Mahomes (Madden NFL 20 and 22) and Lamar Jackson (Madden NFL 21) have dodged the worst of it—but not entirely. Mahomes dealt with nagging injuries. Lamar saw his supporting cast fall apart. Coincidence? Maybe. Or maybe the curse just doesn’t go for kill shots anymore.

Image: Imagn Images

Christian McCaffrey

Christian McCaffrey Injury Update

Christian McCaffrey Madden Cover Curse

Christian McCaffrey Madden Curse

Natasha Bose

I write about sports because, well, it brings in the big bucks! I’m not some lifelong analyst or stats guru, truth being told, you’ve probably never heard of me!—I just know how to research, write, and make things sound good. That’s the job!
Got into sports media the same way most people do: by (fortunate) accident. Started with SEO writing, took on a few sports gigs, and now here we are! I cover games, trades, player drama—whatever needs words.
Favorite part? The chaos. One day it’s a blockbuster trade, the next it’s a goat running onto the field. Never boring.
Message to readers: If you want deep analysis, there are people for that. If you want sharp, no-BS writing that actually makes sense, stick around.