Newcastle United will host Manchester City at St James’ Park on Tuesday, January 13, 2026. The two sides will meet in the first leg of their EFL Cup semi-final. It is a heavyweight domestic clash that pits the reigning EFL Cup holders against a Man City side that is eager to reclaim a trophy they last lifted five years ago in 2021.
Newcastle are arriving with formidable home form and a recent psychological edge in this competition. Whereas, Man City are unbeaten in 12 matches across all competitions. With injuries affecting both squads and a second leg looming at the Etihad, this opener carries strategic importance as much as immediate result value.
You can find more of our soccer predictions on our main picks hub. Here’s how we’re betting Newcastle United vs Manchester City tonight, including our Best Bet, a Same-Game Parlay, and key trends to know.
Newcastle United vs Manchester City Match Details
Competition: EFL Cup Semi-final
Date & kickoff: Tuesday, January 13, 2026 – 3:00 PM ET / 8:00 PM GT
Venue: St. James Park, Newcastle upon Tyne, England
Expected XIs: Newcastle United 4-2-3-1 vs Manchester City 4-1-4-1
Best Bet for Newcastle United vs Manchester City
Our best bet for Newcastle United vs Manchester City is Erling Haaland to Score Anytime (-120) at FanDuel.
Backing Erling Haaland to score anytime remains a logical angle despite Newcastle’s strong home record. Haaland has averaged 0.94 expected goals per 90 minutes across all competitions so far this season. He continues to dominate shot volume and penalty-area touches even when Man City rotate personnel around him.
His physical presence and movement between centre-backs make him particularly effective against teams that defend aggressively in midfield but can be exposed centrally. Newcastle’s defensive numbers at St James’ Park are impressive, but context matters. They’ll have to manage through injuries to key defensive figures.
It includes Jamaal Lascelles and Fabian Schar. It has forced Eddie Howe into rotational solutions at the back. Sven Botman provides aerial dominance. But Newcastle have conceded higher-quality chances when facing elite attacking sides capable of sustaining pressure in the final third. Haaland’s history against Newcastle further supports the bet.
In recent meetings, he has consistently recorded multiple shots on target and posted high xG figures per appearance. That is, even when Man City didn’t dominate possession. With Phil Foden and Rayan Cherki expected to support him creatively, Man City’s chance creation funnels heavily through Haaland in decisive moments.
Newcastle United vs Manchester City Prediction
Our pick: Manchester City to Win at +140 (Both BetMGM and FanDuel)
Manchester City’s plus-money pricing reflects Newcastle’s home strength rather than a clear gap in overall quality. Man City are entering this semi-final unbeaten in 12 straight matches. They’re also posting an average xG differential of +1.72 per game across all competitions so far.
They’ve been driven by their ability to control territory and limit opponents to low-quality chances. Newcastle have gone 13 home matches unbeaten. But many of those fixtures came against sides outside the top tier of attacking efficiency. Against elite opposition, Newcastle’s press can be bypassed.
It forces their back line into repeated recovery defending. Man City’s positional play and off-ball rotations are specifically designed to exploit those moments, especially through half-space overloads. Pep Guardiola’s side also benefit from experience in two-legged knockout ties.
Their approach in first legs away from home is typically measured but opportunistic, prioritizing control while capitalizing on defensive errors. Despite Man City’s recent EFL Cup struggles, their path to this semi-final featured controlled wins over Huddersfield, Swansea, and Brentford, each marked by defensive stability.
New customers only. Must be 21+ in most jurisdictions, but 18+ in DC, KY, and WY. Offer is valid only in eligible regulated states/jurisdictions and not available in AR; void where prohibited. First online real-money wager only; cashed-out or bonus-funded bets are excluded.
Same-Game Parlay (Bet Builder) for Newcastle United vs Manchester City
Bet $100 to Win $396.94 (FanDuel) Total Goals Over 2.5 (-188) + Erling Haaland to score anytime (-120) + Harvey Barnes to either score or assist (+150)
This parlay reflects an open, high-intensity semi-final first leg. Over 2.5 goals have landed in six of Manchester City’s last eight away matches. Newcastle’s recent cup fixtures have also trended toward higher scoring outputs. Haaland anchors the City side of the equation.
Whereas, Harvey Barnes provides Newcastle’s most explosive attacking outlet. Barnes has scored four goals in his last two appearances. His scoring drive has been inspired by high-speed transitions and direct runs into the box. Man City is expected to line up a rotated back line.
They may feature less experienced centre-back pairings which should help Barnes’ ability to attack space behind the fullbacks. The parlay balances Man City’s efficiency with Newcastle’s counter-attacking threat. Thus, aligning with a match script where both sides generate meaningful chances rather than settling into a cautious stalemate.
This builder focuses on the most probable elements of the matchup. Man City’s attacking structure consistently produces high-quality chances for Haaland. Whereas, Newcastle’s home approach encourages aggressive wide play that suits Barnes’ strengths. Both teams are averaging above 1.6 xG per match in recent fixtures. With defensive rotations on both sides, three or more goals remains a realistic expectation.
Newcastle United +170 / Draw +260 / Manchester City +140
Newcastle United +175 / Draw +250 / Manchester City +140
Goals Markets
Over 2.5: -182 / Under 2.5: +135 Over 3.5: +145 / Under 3.5: -192
Over 2.5: -188 / Under 2.5: +142 Over 3.5: +146 / Under 3.5: -192
BTTS
Yes: -225 / No: +155
Yes: -215 / No: +164
Asian Handicap
Newcastle United +1.25: -417 Manchester City -1.25: +300 / -1.50: +340
–
Draw No Bet
Newcastle United: -105 Manchester City: -138
Newcastle United: +100 Manchester City: -130
Double Chance
Newcastle United or Draw: -182 Manchester City or Draw: -238
Newcastle United or Draw: -185 Manchester City or Draw: -240
Trends to Know for Newcastle United vs Manchester City
Head-to-Head at St James’ Park: Newcastle have won two and drawn one of their last four home meetings with City, highlighting their resilience on Tyneside.
Cup History: Newcastle have eliminated Manchester City in each of their last two EFL Cup encounters, adding narrative pressure to this tie.
Home Form: The Magpies are unbeaten in 13 straight home games across all competitions, with 10 wins.
Man City Momentum: Manchester City are unbeaten in 12 matches and have scored multiple goals in five of their last six outings.
Goals Outlook: Both teams rank highly for shots inside the box and non-penalty xG in recent fixtures, supporting the over 2.5 goals market in a high-stakes semi-final first leg.
Latest Injuries & Lineup News for Newcastle United vs Manchester City
In soccer, injuries and rotations can drastically alter how a match plays out, especially when it comes to BTTS, totals, and goalscorer markets. Navigating through a few key injuries in this clash, both coaches will look to lineup their strongest XI. Here are the players who are either doubtful or are set to miss out:
Team
Player
Status
Notes
Newcastle United
Dan Burn
Out
Broken Rib and Punctured Lung
Newcastle United
Emil Krafth
Out
Knee
Newcastle United
Fabian Schar
Out
Ligament Damage
Newcastle United
Jamaal Lascelles
Out
Muscle
Newcastle United
William Osula
Out
Ankle
Newcastle United
Anthony Elanga
Out
Knock
Newcastle United
Valentino Livramento
Doubtful
Hamstring
Man City
Ruben Dias
Out
Hamstring
Man City
Josko Gvardiol
Out
Leg
Man City
Oscar Bobb
Out
Thigh
Man City
Savinho
Out
Unspecified
Man City
John Stones
Out
Thigh
Man City
Mateo Kovacic
Out
Ankle
Man City
Rayan Ait-Nouri
Out
International Duty
Man City
Omar Marmoush
Out
International Duty
Reminder: Always check confirmed lineups 60–75 minutes before kickoff, especially for goalscorer and BTTS markets.
How to watch – quick Q&A
What time is Newcastle United vs Manchester City?
Newcastle United vs Manchester City kicks off at 3:00 PM ET on Tuesday, January 13, 2026 (8:00 PM local UK time).
Where is the match being played?
The match will be played at St. James Park in Newcastle upon Tyne, England.
How can I watch on TV / stream?
Broadcast rights vary by territory. In the US, the FA Cup semi-final can be telecast on Paramount+. In the UK, it will be telecast on Sky Sports. The match will also be available to stream on these broadcasters’ official websites.
Football writer at The Playoffs. I’ve been obsessed with the beautiful game since I was a kid.. Eventually, I realized I could combine my passion for writing with my love for football, and I’ve never looked back. My favorite part of the job is everything—when you’re doing what you love, even a late-night deadline feels like extra time in a thrilling cup final. Lastly, Lionel Messi is the GOAT.
soccer 
