Image Credit - Christine Tannous/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Indiana Fever Face Uncertain Offseason With Key Contracts, Injuries And Expansion Draft Looming Over Roster Decisions

Image Credit - Christine Tannous/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Indiana Fever closed their season with a roster that looked far different from the one that began it, and the changes may only accelerate next year. With the current collective bargaining agreement set to expire after the 2025 season, many players signed short‑term deals, leaving the team facing a potentially turbulent offseason.

The looming expiration of the CBA means a larger pool of free agents in 2026, while the addition of new franchises in Portland and Toronto will further complicate roster construction through an expansion draft. Teams are limited to 11 or 12 players, but the Indiana Fever cycled through 18 this season, finishing the semifinals with six players sidelined by injuries, including star Caitlin Clark.

Clark is one of only three players already under contract for next season, alongside Aaliyah Boston and Makayla Timpson, all on rookie deals. Lexie Hull, who became a crucial contributor late in the year, enters restricted free agency, giving Indiana Fever the right to match outside offers. “I built a life here, and I love this franchise,” Hull said during her exit interview. “I love the people and the fans, so we’ll see what comes.”

So much to be proud of ❤️❤️ shoutout the fans for staying with us all year❤️❤️🙏🏻 @IndianaFever
— Caitlin Clark (@CaitlinClark22) October 1, 2025

General manager Amber Cox emphasized the organization’s desire to retain much of the current roster but singled out one player as the top priority. “The priority will be Kelsey Mitchell and making sure she remains in a Fever jersey,” Cox said. If the new CBA maintains the core player designation, Indiana Fever could use it on Mitchell, securing exclusive negotiating rights for a one‑year supermax contract.

Indiana Fever Fans Should Expect More Roster Changes Next Year

Kelsey Mitchell, however, stopped short of committing to a return. Calling Indianapolis her “second family,” she acknowledged her affection for the franchise but noted that family considerations remain central following her father’s unexpected passing last year. “Family is big for me,” she said. “Talking to them and figuring out what’s best for us … is always going to be important.”

That uncertainty extends to other key contributors. Starter Natasha Howard’s future is unclear, while Odyssey Sims, initially signed on a hardship waiver, became a difference‑maker after joining in August.

Injured players Aari McDonald and Sophie Cunningham also face decisions. Cunningham, recovering from an MCL injury, admitted she must consider other opportunities but expressed a strong desire to stay. “I have loved being here,” she said. “I’ve never been a part of a team like this. … Of course, you want to come back.”

The Fever’s season forced fans to accept constant roster turnover. With contract questions, expansion pressures, and injuries still in play, next year promises more of the same.