Sports
NBA PLAYOFFS
Picks & Odds
Betting Guide
Casinos

Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Predictions, Odds, Bets & Player Props ECSF Game 1– 05/04/2025

Shubham Singh
Basketball / NBA
04/05/2025 – 21:00
Cleveland Cavaliers
VS
21:00
04/05/2025
Indiana Pacers
Odds updated on May 3, 2025 at 12:28 pm

On Tuesday, 04/27, the Cleveland Cavaliers will host the Indiana Pacers in Game 1 of the NBA Eastern Conference Semi-Finals. The Cavaliers historically swept the Miami Heat during round one, whereas the Pacers made light work of the Milwaukee Bucks in five games. Can the No. 1 seed Cavs keep a deep Pacers at bay? Read through the preview, total predictions, and player props here.

Where to Watch Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers

  • Time: 6:00 PM (ET) 
  • Venue: Rocket Arena (Cleveland, Ohio)
  • Where to watch: This game can be viewed on the NBA League Pass.

Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Series Lookahead

The Pacers face an uphill climb, but they are ready for the job

The Cavaliers beat the Heat by 55 points in Game 4 and 37 in Game 3. No team has ever won this big in back-to-back games. The Cavs scored 120+ in all the games against a team with a top-ten defensive lineup in the Regular Season. That says it all. 

Meanwhile, the Pacers faced fiercer resistance. However, they stamped a gentleman’s sweep too. Game 5 went to Overtime, but Tyrese Haliburton kept his cool to nail the game-winning shot. Apart from that, they had two wins by 19 or more points and lost Game 3 by 16 points.

However, the Bucks were a one-man army, led by Giannis Antetokounmpo. The Cavs are far from that. Their ace Donovan Mitchell scored just 13 points in Game 3, and they won by 37! It shows immense depth. Darius Garland is a terrific shooter and playmaker whereas the frontcourt of Evan Mobley and Jarrett Allen is one of the best. Their bench with DeAndre Hunter and Ty Jerome has also played a decisive role.

The Pacers are also a den of talent. Haliburton has been in impeccable form, whereas his fellow guards, Andrew Nembhard, T.J. McConnell, and Benedict Mathurin, are all capable starting-level players. Aaron Nesmith has been fantastic during the playoffs, whereas the frontline of Myles Turner and Pascal Siakam is as good as it gets.

Both teams are blessed with a wealth of talent and are deep at almost all positions. Thus, this series can be a long one, unlike the short and underwhelming first-round affairs. 

Pacers Expected Starting Lineup

PG: Tyrese Haliburton | SG: Andrew Nembhard | SF: Aaron Nesmith | PF: Pascal Siakam | C: Myles Turner

Key bench players: SG: Benedict Mathurin, PG: TJ McConnell, SF: Jarace Walker, PF: Obi Toppin

Injuries/Updates: Isaiah Jackson is OUT for the game.

Cavaliers Expected Starting Lineup

PG: Darius Garland | SG: Donovan Mitchell | SF: Max Strus | PF: Evan Mobley | C: Jarrett Allen

Key bench players: SG: Ty Jerome, SF: DeAndre Hunter,

Injuries/Updates: Nothing significant to report.

Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Total Over/Under Prediction: NBA Betting Picks

Both teams are capable of scoring 120+ as they have a world of shot-creators. They can hit long-range bombs at a high rate and can also finish through contact. Thus, the chances of a high-scoring series are high.

If we exclude the last game of the Regular Season Series(starters were resting), the lowest total was a respectable 112 by the Pacers. Both teams crossed 120+ once, and that can be the template of the series.

But then again, it is the playoffs where referees allow more contact, and players also want to play high-intensity games. Thus, it can bring down the scoring.

The bookmakers are projecting a score of around 230. I agree with a similar range. I’d go for the “Over” mark, but it feels like it will be touch-and-go here.

Get up 1,500$ back in bonus bet if your first bet doesn’t win !
Click to copy code
COPIED
TPOTODAY
Claim $1,500
21+. AZ/CO/IL/IN/IA/KS/LA/MD/MA/MI/NJ/OH/PA/TN/ VA/WV/WY only. Offer not available in DC/MS/NV/NY/PR. New customers only. Qualifying deposit (min $10) and first real money wager required. If qualifying bet settles as a loss, user is refunded 100% in non-withdrawable bonus bets up to $1,500. Full T&Cs can be found on betmgm.com.

Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Player Props Predictions- NBA Best Picks

Donovan Mitchell to score over 25.5 points: Mitchell had 35 points and 19 points in two games against Indiana this season. He can fancy a big night despite suffering from multiple injuries. I see him scoring around 25.

Tyrese Haliburton to dish over 10.5 assists: Haliburton had 10 and 5 assists in two games against the Cavs during the Regular Season. He averaged 11.6 helpers against the Bucks in the First Round. I believe he will dish at least 11 assists here.

Jarrett Allen to grab over 10.5 rebounds: The Cavs Center gathered 9.3 rebounds per game in three matches against the Pacers. He accumulated 10.3 RPG in the first round series, and I see him going around a similar number.

Main pick: Jarrett Allen O 10.5 rebounds for -118 at BetMGM

Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Game 1 Prediction- NBA Betting Lines

This is a perfect match-up. Both teams have a ton of confidence and are tailor-made for postseason play. Indiana is riding their 2024 postseason form when it made it past the East Semis. Meanwhile, Cleveland is playing exquisite team basketball that has championship potential.

I see the Cavaliers starting the series with a bang, but have some doubts about the allotted spread of -8.5 in their favor. I see the Pacers losing by 5-7 points, hence, covering the spread by a whisker perhaps.

Betting Lines:

  • Total: O 229.5: -110. U: -110
  • Spread: Cavs -8.5: -105. Pacers: +8.5: -115

Safe Spread Pick:  Pacers +7.5 for +105 at BetMGM 

Photo Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images

nba nba

Hi, I am Shubham. I am currently an NBA Predictions Writer on The Playoffs. I enjoy this job because it helps keep me in the loop about the game I love while fulfilling the pleasure I derive from stats. I got into NBA writing through social media interactions in the mid-2010s as I shared my takes on young talents such as D’Angelo Russell. I hope you enjoy reading my pieces as much as Dennis Rodman loved rebounding the basketball!

Read more
instagram

Sign up for The Playoffs
Newsletter

Get the biggest stories delivered straight to you - for free!

By signing up, you consent to our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy, nad to receive marketing and account-related emails from The Playoffs. You can subscribe at any time.