NFL Coach of the Year Odds Week 18 – Mike Vrabel Leads the Pack for the 2025-26 NFL COTY Award

As the 2025 NFL regular season concludes, the Associated Press Coach of the Year award or in simple words AP COTY award, stands out as one of the most compelling and wide-open races in recent memory. Unlike many seasons dominated by a single frontrunner, 2025-26 features several coaches who orchestrated remarkable turnarounds that few prognosticators foresaw.

Candidates like New England’s Mike Vrabel, who transformed a Patriots squad into a playoff contender, exemplify this trend. Similar unexpected surges from coaches in Seattle, Denver, Chicago, and elsewhere have created a crowded field of deserving recipients.

What makes this award particularly intriguing is the sheer number of viable stories. And voters face a difficult choice among multiple coaches who exceeded sky-high expectations. In the end, only one will claim the prestigious honor, leaving several equally worth campaigns without the ultimate recognition.

Updated 2025-26 NFL COTY Odds

Here are the latest NFL Coach of the Year odds for the 2025-26 NFL season at the end of the regular season, sourced via FanDuel and BetMGM.

Coach	Fanduel Odds	BetMGM Odds
Mike Vrabel	-370	-285
Mike MacDonald	+410	+300
Liam Coen	+700	+1800
Ben Johnson	+8000	+1800
Sean Payton	+20000	+1600
Kyle Shanahan	+30000	+4000

BetMGM

All in one gambling website

Reputable gambling name

Multiple betting features including live streaming

$1,500

Welcome offer

Get up to $1,500 Back in Bonus Bets

Click to copy code

COPIED

TPOVIP

Claim now

21+. AZ/CO/IL/IN/IA/KS/LA/MD/MA/MI/NJ/OH/PA/TN/ VA/WV/WY only. Offer not available in DC/MS/NV/NY/PR. New customers only. Qualifying deposit (min $10) and first real money wager required. If qualifying bet settles as a loss, user is refunded 100% in non-withdrawable bonus bets up to $1,500. Full T&Cs can be found on betmgm.com.

2025-26 NFL Coach of the Year Favorites Right Now

Let us take a look at the top 3 favorites to land the NFL Coach of the Year award this season.

Mike Vrabel (-370)

Mike Vrabel leads NFL Coach of the Year odds at -370 on Fanduel due to engineering the most dramatic turnaround in recent history. In his first season with New England, he transformed a Patriot team coming off back-to-back 4-13 finishes into a 14-3 AFC East champion, tying the biggest win improvement ever. Central to this resurgence is second-year QB Drake Maye’s breakout under Vrabel’s guidance and OC Josh McDaniels, Maye posted elite stats like a 72% completion rate and 113.5 passer rating, emerging as an MVP contender. Vrabel’s tough, fundamentals-focused style restored defensive identity and offensive explosiveness, making him the clear frontrunner.

Mike MacDonald (+410)

Mike MacDonald ranks as a top contender for NFL Coach of the Years odds behind only Mike Vrabel. In his second season with Seattle, he guided the Seahawks from a 10-7-non-playoff finish in 2024 to a franchise-best 14-3 recrd, clinching the NFC West and the No.1 seed with a bye. MacDonald rebuilt an elite defense (top-ranked in points allowed and run stoppage) while hiring OC Klint Kubiak to revive the offense around a resurgent Sam Darnold, turning preseason underdogs into Super Bowl favorites through innovative schemes and culture reset.

FanDuel

High total bonus ceiling

Daily second-chance bet protection

No promo code required

$150

Welcome offer

Bet $5 & Get $150 in Bonus Bets

Click to reveal code

COPIED

F A N D U V I P

Claim now

New customers only. Must be 21+ in most jurisdictions, but 18+ in DC, KY, and WY. Offer is valid only in eligible regulated states/jurisdictions and not available in AR; void where prohibited. First online real-money wager only; cashed-out or bonus-funded bets are excluded.

Liam Coen (+700)

Liam Coen ranks as a strong contender for NFL Coach of the Year odds trailing favorites like Mike Vrabel. In his debut season as Jacksonville Jaguars head coach, he flipped a 4-win 2024 team into a 13-4 AFC South champion and , marking one of history’s biggest turnarounds, matching rare feats like the 1999 Colts. Coen’s innovative offense unlocked Trevor Lawrence’s elite play, boosting scoring dramatically while fostering resilience through an eight-game win streak. His rapid success as a first-year HC elevates him prominently.

The above odds are sourced from FanDuel. Use FanDuel to ace your betting game in all sports!

Eric Divakaran

nba

nfl

mma

I cover the National Football League and things cannot get better than that. I always dreamed to play football or basketball professionally since I’m built like a Running Back. But now that I can’t, since I’m technically in the “Unc” age, I thought why not pick a career in sports industry? So here I am, doing what I love, and hoping that the Commanders win the Super Bowl. I give love to players when it’s due, but can be critical about their performances at the same time. Enough about me, now let my articles do all the talking.