According to a recent survey conducted by MLB.com during spring training, over 100 players anonymously shared their picks for the team most likely to exceed expectations in 2025. Every season, an underdog story emerges, surprising fans and analysts alike. Last year, the players correctly identified the Kansas City Royals, a team coming off a 106-loss season, as a breakout candidate. The Royals went on to finish 86-76 and clinched a postseason berth. Now, the question is: which team will shock everyone in 2025? Here’s what the players had to say.<\/p>
The overwhelming favorite among surveyed players, the Athletics received at least 10 more votes than any other team. Despite their struggles in recent years, many believe Oakland’s offense is poised to break out.<\/p>
“I think the A’s are going to be able to swing it,”<\/em> one American League starting pitcher said. “Their second half last year showed they were putting things together offensively. I’m not sure about their pitching depth, but their lineup should be solid.”<\/em><\/p> Another player, a National League reliever, pointed to the talent on the roster, particularly outfielder Lawrence Butler, who recently signed a seven-year, $65.5 million extension. The A’s also bolstered their roster with versatile infielders Luis Urías and Gio Urshela, former ace Luis Severino, a healthy Jeffrey Springs, and high-strikeout closer José Leclerc.<\/p>