Before diving into this debate, let’s just establish that I’m not neutral here. But even if I try my best to see this from an objective standpoint, calling Juan Soto the biggest star in New York feels like a stretch.<\/p>
Sure, Juan Soto is a generational talent. Sure, he’s fresh off a record-breaking 15-year, $765 million deal with the Mets<\/a>. But are we really putting him above Aaron Judge? If we’re talking pure talent and body of work, are we really going down a road that puts Juan Soto over Aaron Judge?<\/p> In a city full of superstars, it’s always the 6-foot-7 giant from the Bronx that shines the brightest. Maybe if someone argued Karl-Anthony Towns deserved a higher spot, there’s a conversation to be had. But Juan Soto over Aaron Judge?<\/p>The Bronx belongs to Aaron Judge<\/h2>